New Post

In partnership with

In business school, they teach you about success. They analyze the unicorns, the market disruptors, and the hockey-stick growth charts.

They rarely teach you about the crater.

I’m writing this because we recently climbed out of one. It wasn’t a slow leak or a minor rounding error. It was a strategic misfire that ended up costing our organization—in sunk costs, lost revenue, and damage control—roughly $50 million.

Staring at an eight-figure loss on a spreadsheet is a humbling experience. The boardroom silence that follows is deafening.

But if you waste a crisis, you've truly failed. Tuition for the "School of Hard Knocks" is expensive, so you’d better make sure you attend the lectures.

We are finally on the other side of it, bruised but smarter. Here is the autopsy of a $50 million mistake, and the three critical lessons we learned the hard way.

The Anatomy of the Failure

I won’t bore you with the specific confidential details of the product launch, but the shape of the failure will feel familiar to many leaders.

We weren't taken down by competitors. We weren't taken down by the economy. We were taken down by certainty.

We had a track record of success. We had brilliant engineers and charismatic marketers. We convinced ourselves that we knew exactly what the market needed, to the point where we stopped asking them if they actually wanted it.

We poured massive resources into a platform based on a hypothesis that we treated as fact. When the launch day arrived, the market responded with a collective shrug. We had built a Ferrari when the customers just wanted a faster bicycle.

Here are the lessons that cost us $50 million to learn.

Lesson 1: Success Breeds Dangerous Insulation

When you are winning, it becomes very easy to curate your environment.

During the two years leading up to this failure, our organization had fallen into a subtle trap: we started promoting the cheerleaders and sidelining the cynics.

The people who raised red flags about the new direction were viewed as "not being on board with the vision" or "lacking an agile mindset." Gradually, the voices of dissent went quiet. We created an echo chamber where bad ideas sounded brilliant because everyone was nodding agreement.

The Takeaway: If everyone in the room agrees with you, someone isn’t thinking. You must actively incentivize dissent. Designate a "Red Team" whose only job is to poke holes in your expensive assumptions before you sign the check.

Lesson 2: Beware of "Vanity Data" (Confirmation Bias on Steroids)

Did we have data supporting our massive investment? Absolutely. We had terabytes of it.

But we were victims of severe confirmation bias. We were looking for data to prove we were right, rather than data to test if we were right.

We focused obsessively on "vanity metrics"—early sign-ups from early adopters, enthusiastic feedback from a tiny sample size of super-users—and ignored the boring foundational metrics, like broad market appeal and actual willingness to pay. We saw the green lights because we were wearing green-tinted glasses.

The Takeaway: Data is useless if you lack the intellectual honesty to interpret it correctly. Stop asking, " Does this data support my idea?" Start asking, "What is the quickest way to prove this idea is wrong?" The sooner you find the kill switch on a bad idea, the cheaper it is.

Lesson 3: Momentum is Not the Same as Progress

This was the hardest pill to swallow. We worked so hard on this mistake.

Our teams were pulling 60-hour weeks. The Jira boards were moving fast. We were hitting milestones ahead of schedule. The momentum was intoxicating. We felt like we were flying.

It turns out, we were just running at full speed toward a cliff edge.

We confused velocity (speed in a specific direction) with just plain speed. We were so busy executing that we forgot to strategy-check. We were efficient at doing the wrong thing.

The Takeaway: Periodically stop the assembly line. It doesn't matter how fast the train is moving if the tracks are leading to the wrong station. Take time to zoom out from the daily grind to ensure the ultimate destination hasn't shifted.

The Expensive Silver Lining

Nobody wants a $50 million scar on their resume. It was embarrassing, stressful, and it kept me awake for months.

But today, our company culture is radically different. We are more humble. We listen better. We test faster and cheaper. We celebrate the person who finds the flaw in the plan before launch.

That $50 million was the most expensive tuition I’ve ever paid. But the education we got might just be priceless.

Have you ever been part of a massive corporate blunder? What was the biggest lesson you pulled from the wreckage? Let me know in the comments.

Introducing the first AI-native CRM

Connect your email, and you’ll instantly get a CRM with enriched customer insights and a platform that grows with your business.

With AI at the core, Attio lets you:

• Prospect and route leads with research agents

• Get real-time insights during customer calls

• Build powerful automations for your complex workflows

Join industry leaders like Granola, Taskrabbit, Flatfile and more.

👉Try Attio Pro for free

Subscribe to Travis to read the rest.